Project Euler Problem 277
A modified Collatz sequence of integers is obtained from a starting value a1 in the following way: a{n+1} = frac {an} 3
Solution
Answer: 1125977393124310
Let the required step string be
$$S=\texttt{UDDDUdddDDUDDddDdDddDDUDDdUUDd}$$
We seek the smallest integer $a_1>10^{15}$ whose modified Collatz trajectory begins with exactly these steps.
1. Mathematical analysis
The rules are:
- $D:\quad a_{n+1}=\dfrac{a_n}{3}$, valid when $a_n\equiv0\pmod3$
- $U:\quad a_{n+1}=\dfrac{4a_n+2}{3}$, valid when $a_n\equiv1\pmod3$
- $d:\quad a_{n+1}=\dfrac{2a_n-1}{3}$, valid when $a_n\equiv2\pmod3$
The key observation is:
Each step is an affine linear transformation.
So after a whole string of steps, the starting value is an affine function of the ending value.
Working backwards
Suppose after all steps we end at some integer $x$.
We invert each operation.
Inverse of $D$
$$a_n = 3a_{n+1}$$
Inverse of $U$
$$a_{n+1}=\frac{4a_n+2}{3}$$
so
$$a_n=\frac{3a_{n+1}-2}{4}$$
Inverse of $d$
$$a_{n+1}=\frac{2a_n-1}{3}$$
so
$$a_n=\frac{3a_{n+1}+1}{2}$$
We now process the required string backwards.
Let the final value after all steps be $x$.
After symbolically composing all inverse maps, we obtain
$$a_1 = \frac{205891132094649,x+21110037246199}{2^{22}}$$
Thus $a_1$ is an integer iff
$$205891132094649,x+21110037246199 \equiv 0 \pmod{2^{22}}$$
Since $2^{22}=4194304$, reduce coefficients modulo $4194304$:
$$686265x+356599\equiv0\pmod{4194304}$$
Because
$$\gcd(686265,4194304)=1,$$
there is a unique solution modulo $4194304$.
Solving gives
$$x\equiv 1966289 \pmod{4194304}.$$
So write
$$x=1966289+4194304k.$$
Substitute into the affine expression for $a_1$:
$$a_1 = 96521732651065 + 205891132094649,k.$$
We now choose the smallest $k$ such that
$$a_1>10^{15}.$$
That is,
$$96521732651065+205891132094649,k>10^{15}.$$
This gives
$$k=5.$$
Hence
$$a_1 = 96521732651065 + 5\cdot205891132094649 = 1125977393124310.$$
2. Python implementation
from math import gcd
# Required step sequence
s = "UDDDUdddDDUDDddDdDddDDUDDdUUDd"
# We derive:
# a1 = (A*x + B) / M
# where x is the value AFTER all steps.
A = 1
B = 0
M = 1
# Process inverses in reverse order
for ch in reversed(s):
if ch == 'D':
# x -> 3x
A *= 3
B *= 3
elif ch == 'U':
# x -> (3x - 2)/4
A *= 3
B = 3 * B - 2
M *= 4
elif ch == 'd':
# x -> (3x + 1)/2
A *= 3
B = 3 * B + 1
M *= 2
# Need:
# A*x + B ≡ 0 (mod M)
a = A % M
b = B % M
# modular inverse since gcd(a, M)=1
inv = pow(a, -1, M)
x0 = (-b * inv) % M
# General solution:
# x = x0 + M*k
#
# Then:
# a1 = (A*x + B)/M
#
# = base + A*k
base = (A * x0 + B) // M
step = A
LIMIT = 10**15
k = (LIMIT - base + step) // step
answer = base + step * k
print(answer)
3. Code walkthrough
Building the affine form
We process the sequence backwards because the inverse formulas are simple linear maps.
We maintain:
$$a_1 = \frac{A x + B}{M}$$
where $x$ is the unknown endpoint after the entire sequence.
Each inverse step updates $A,B,M$.
Solving integrality
For $a_1$ to be an integer:
$$A x + B \equiv 0 \pmod M.$$
This is a linear congruence.
Because $A$ is invertible modulo $M$, there is exactly one residue class modulo $M$.
Generating all solutions
Every valid solution is:
$$x=x_0+Mk.$$
Substituting into the affine formula yields:
$$a_1=\text{base}+A k.$$
So the valid starting values form an arithmetic progression.
We choose the smallest one exceeding $10^{15}$.
4. Verification
The obtained value is:
$$1125977393124310$$
which is indeed:
- larger than $10^{15}$,
- in the correct arithmetic progression,
- and known to be the official Project Euler answer.
Also note the smaller example from the statement:
- for the sequence
DdDddUUdDD, - the same method gives $1004064$,
- matching the problem statement exactly.
Therefore the derivation is consistent.
Answer: 1125977393124310