Project Euler Problem 475
12n musicians participate at a music festival.
Solution
Answer: 75780067
Let the $12n$ musicians be divided into $3n$ fixed quartets from day 1:
$$Q_1,Q_2,\dots,Q_{3n}, \qquad |Q_i|=4.$$
On day 2 we must partition all musicians into $4n$ unordered trios such that no trio contains two members from the same quartet.
We seek
$$f(12n).$$
1. Mathematical analysis
Step 1: Start from all trio partitions
The number of ways to partition $12n$ labeled people into $4n$ unordered trios is
$$\frac{(12n)!}{(3!)^{4n}(4n)!} = \frac{(12n)!}{6^{4n}(4n)!}.$$
Now impose the restrictions.
Step 2: Inclusion–exclusion
Inside each quartet there are
$$\binom{4}{2}=6$$
forbidden pairs.
Let an event $E_{ab}$ mean:
musicians $a,b$ (from the same quartet) appear in the same trio.
We apply inclusion–exclusion over all forbidden pairs.
Step 3: What subsets of forbidden pairs are feasible?
Fix one quartet with vertices ${1,2,3,4}$.
We choose a subset $S$ of its 6 edges.
A selected edge means that pair must lie in a common trio.
Since a trio has size 3, every connected component of the graph $({1,2,3,4},S)$ must have size at most 3.
The only feasible graph types are:
| Type | Count | Sign | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| empty | 1 | $+$ | nothing |
| one edge | 6 | $-$ | one forced pair |
| two disjoint edges | 3 | $+$ | two forced pairs |
| connected 3-vertex graph with 2 edges | 12 | $+$ | one forced triple |
| triangle | 4 | $-$ | one forced triple |
The last two both force the same thing: all 3 vertices must lie in one trio.
Thus the net contribution for one quartet is
$$P(x,y)=1-6x+3x^2+8y,$$
where
- $x$ counts a forced pair-component,
- $y$ counts a forced triple-component.
Since quartets are independent, for all $3n$ quartets:
$$P(x,y)^{3n}.$$
Let
$$[x^a y^b]P(x,y)^{3n}=c_{a,b}.$$
Then:
- $a$ = number of forced pairs,
- $b$ = number of forced triples.
Step 4: Count completions for fixed $(a,b)$
A forced triple already occupies one trio.
A forced pair must be completed by one additional singleton.
After fixing:
- $a$ pair-components,
- $b$ triple-components,
the remaining number of free singletons is
$$12n-2a-3b.$$
We must choose distinct singleton partners for the $a$ pairs:
$$\frac{(12n-2a-3b)!}{(12n-3a-3b)!}.$$
The remaining
$$12n-3a-3b = 3(4n-a-b)$$
singletons are partitioned into
$$4n-a-b$$
unordered trios:
$$\frac{(12n-3a-3b)!}{6^{4n-a-b}(4n-a-b)!}.$$
Multiplying:
$$\frac{(12n-2a-3b)!}{6^{4n-a-b}(4n-a-b)!}.$$
Therefore
$$\boxed{ f(12n)= \sum_{a,b} c_{a,b} \frac{(12n-2a-3b)!} {6^{,4n-a-b}(4n-a-b)!} }$$
where
$$c_{a,b}=x^a y^b^{3n}.$$
2. Python implementation
MOD = 1_000_000_007
def solve(n):
# DP for coefficients of:
# (1 - 6x + 3x^2 + 8y)^(3n)
from collections import defaultdict
dp = {(0, 0): 1}
for _ in range(3 * n):
ndp = defaultdict(int)
for (a, b), v in dp.items():
# 1
ndp[(a, b)] = (ndp[(a, b)] + v) % MOD
# -6x
ndp[(a + 1, b)] = (ndp[(a + 1, b)] - 6 * v) % MOD
# +3x^2
ndp[(a + 2, b)] = (ndp[(a + 2, b)] + 3 * v) % MOD
# +8y
ndp[(a, b + 1)] = (ndp[(a, b + 1)] + 8 * v) % MOD
dp = ndp
# factorials
N = 12 * n
fact = [1] * (N + 1)
for i in range(1, N + 1):
fact[i] = fact[i - 1] * i % MOD
invfact = [1] * (4 * n + 1)
invfact[4 * n] = pow(fact[4 * n], MOD - 2, MOD)
for i in range(4 * n, 0, -1):
invfact[i - 1] = invfact[i] * i % MOD
inv6 = pow(6, MOD - 2, MOD)
pow_inv6 = [1] * (4 * n + 1)
for i in range(1, 4 * n + 1):
pow_inv6[i] = pow_inv6[i - 1] * inv6 % MOD
ans = 0
for (a, b), c in dp.items():
m = 12 * n - 2 * a - 3 * b
k = 4 * n - a - b
if m < 0 or k < 0:
continue
term = c
term %= MOD
term *= fact[m]
term %= MOD
term *= pow_inv6[k]
term %= MOD
term *= invfact[k]
term %= MOD
ans += term
ans %= MOD
return ans % MOD
# Checks from the problem statement
print(solve(1)) # 576
print(solve(2)) # 509089824
# Required answer
print(solve(50))
3. Code walkthrough
Polynomial DP
We build coefficients of
$$(1-6x+3x^2+8y)^{3n}$$
using dynamic programming.
Each quartet contributes one factor.
The state:
dp[(a,b)]
stores the coefficient of $x^a y^b$.
Factorials
We need terms of the form
$$\frac{m!}{6^k k!}.$$
Modulo arithmetic uses Fermat inverses because
$$10^9+7$$
is prime.
Final summation
For every coefficient $c_{a,b}$, we add
$$c_{a,b} \cdot \frac{(12n-2a-3b)!} {6^{4n-a-b}(4n-a-b)!}.$$
4. Verification
The program reproduces both given values:
$$f(12)=576$$
and
$$f(24)\bmod 10^9+7 = 509089824.$$
So the derivation is consistent.
Running the computation for $n=50$ gives:
$$f(600)\bmod 1,000,000,007 = 75780067.$$
Answer: 75780067